- Butt: no
- Misbah: meh, does not emanate great authority, but is an old warhorse with ok stats
- Afridi: a disgrace to the spirit of the game, blatant pitch tamperer, ball tamperer, blackmailer, and overrated batsman, whose presence on the wicket tempts his partners into playing retarded shots. Has no clue about the difference between leadership and impertinence. Rewarding such behaviour by granting him the captaincy is like making a German catholic priest leader of the boyscouts: WRONG. It's in the hands of the PCB to decide if the pig inherits the farm. But be aware of the signals it sends out. To the worldwide audience, to the Pakistani players and the cricket youth.
- Razzaq: brain + batting style + impressive form + anger
Issue solved, case closed, stop fussing about.